Illinois Institute of Technology · Elevate Experiences

Always Follow Up

What to send, when to send it, and what to do when nobody replies.

Most people don’t follow up. That’s your opening: a short, specific email puts you back in front of someone while they’re deciding.

Key Concepts

Six Things to Walk Away With

If you read nothing else, read these.

01

The 24-Hour Rule

Someone gave you their time? They get an email within 24 hours.

02

Events: 48 Hours

After a fair or networking night, email within 48 hours. Connect on LinkedIn the same day.

03

No Reply? 10, 21, Stop

One nudge at day 7–10, a final note around day 21, then stop.

04

Under 150 Words

Subject, context, one specific detail, one ask, a close. It should fit on a phone screen.

05

One Real Detail

Mention something only your conversation produced. That line gets the reply.

06

Add Something

A follow-up that adds value, like a document, an update, or a result, is never pestering.

· · ·

The Workbook

Work Through It

9 Sections · Tap a Question to Open It

Not sure where to start? Start with 1. Need to send something right now? Go to 7.

1What goes in a follow-up email?
The Follow-Up Formula
▾
  1. Subject: what it is, for which role or event, and when.
  2. Context: one line on who you are and where you met.
  3. Specific: one real detail only your conversation produced.
  4. Ask: one easy-to-answer request, or an offer to send something.
  5. Close: thanks and the next step. No apology.
SituationSend it
Someone gave you their timeWithin 24 hours
You met at an eventWithin 48 hours; LinkedIn the same day
You applied7–10 business days; if the posting gave a date, two business days after it
Nobody repliedDay 7–10, then day 21, then stop
Weak Subject Line

“Following up”

Strong Subject Line

“Thank you—Data Analyst Intern interview, Tuesday”

Why it works: They know what it is and whether it needs action before they open it.

Try It

Write the subject line for the next follow-up you owe someone.

2I applied. Now what?
After You Apply
▾

Your follow-up won’t change how the software ranks you. It can put a person in the loop, and a person can go look.

  • The day you apply: save the posting as a PDF. Note the title, date, and requisition number.
  • The same week: find a person. A named recruiter, the hiring manager, or an Illinois Tech alum on the team. Try the Career Services LinkedIn Index and the Alumni Mentorship Program.
  • 7–10 business days later: one short email with the role, the requisition number, and one piece of evidence. Use template 7.
  • If the posting says no follow-up, respect it completely.
  • If you’re rejected, reply anyway. Use template 11.

Try It

Start a tracker. One row per application.

EmployerRole / Req #AppliedContactFollowed Up
     
     
3What do I send after an interview?
After an Interview
▾
  • Send a separate note to each interviewer, and make each one different. Interviewers compare notes.
  • Missing a name or title? Ask the recruiter. That’s a normal request.
  • Send it even if the interview went badly. Composure afterward is evidence too.
  • Fumbled a question? Add one sentence: “On your question about [X], the clearer answer is…” One correction, not five.

Try It

Fill in the line that makes it yours, then paste it into template 1: “I especially appreciated what you said about ________, because ________.”

4I met someone at a career fair. What next?
After a Career Fair or Event
▾
  • Same day: connect on LinkedIn with a note (template 5). A bare request is forgettable.
  • Within 48 hours: email, naming the conversation. “We talked about your Rockford plant and whether a materials background transfers.”
  • Do what you said you would, and say so in the email.
  • Apply anyway, separately. A good conversation is not an application. See Jobs and Internships.

Full fair strategy is on Work the Room.

Try It

Write the one detail from your conversation that only that recruiter would recognize.

5How do I thank someone for advice?
After an Informational Interview
▾

The Email Almost Nobody Sends

Two or three months later, tell them what you did with their advice.

It tells them their time mattered, and it reopens the conversation without asking for anything. Use template 6.

Send the thank-you within 24 hours (template 2). Setting up these conversations is covered on Informational Interviews and Network and Make Connections.

Try It

Write the advice you got and the date you’ll send the update. Put that date on your calendar now.

6They haven’t replied. Do I write again?
When Nobody Replies
▾

Silence usually means busy, not no. Treat it as a scheduling problem, not a verdict.

WhenWhat to send
Day 0The original email or application.
Day 7–10One short nudge in the same thread. Add something new if you can (template 9).
Day 21A final, gracious note. Say you’ll stop and leave the door open (template 10).
After thatNothing by email. Stay visible on LinkedIn or at events they host.
Pushy

“Just checking in again! Did you get my email?”

Professional

“Following up on my note below. Since I wrote, I finished [X]. Happy to send anything that would help.”

Why it works: It adds something new and makes replying easy.

7I need to send something now.
14 Fill-In Templates
▾

Replace everything in [red brackets]. Make the specific line truly specific. That’s the part that gets the reply.

1 · After an interviewWithin 24 hours, one per interviewer

Subject  Thank you—[Role] interview, [Day]

Dear [Name],

Thank you for taking the time to speak with me [today/yesterday] about the [Role] position.

I especially appreciated what you said about [specific thing they said], because [one sentence connecting it to your work or interest].

The conversation left me more interested in the role. If it would help, I am glad to send [the project, sample, or document you mentioned].

Thank you again, and I look forward to hearing about next steps.

Best regards,
[Your name]
[Program], Class of [Year] · Illinois Tech
[Phone] · [LinkedIn URL]

2 · After an informational interviewWithin 24 hours

Subject  Thank you—our conversation about [field or role]

Dear [Name],

Thank you for the time [today/yesterday]. Your advice to [their specific advice] was exactly what I needed to hear.

My next step is to [what you will do and by when]. I will let you know how it goes.

Thank you again for your generosity.

Best regards,
[Your name]
[Program], Class of [Year] · Illinois Tech
[Phone] · [LinkedIn URL]

3 · Thanking a referenceWhen they agree, and again when you hear back

Subject  Thank you—and an update on [Role or Program]

Dear [Name],

Thank you for serving as a reference for my application to [role or program]. I know it took your time, and I appreciate it.

[Update: I was offered the position / I am still waiting to hear / the process ended, and here is what I learned.]

I will keep you posted, and I am grateful for your support.

Best regards,
[Your name]

4 · After a career fair or eventWithin 48 hours

Subject  Great to meet you at the [Event], [Day]

Dear [Name],

We spoke on [day] at the [event] about [topic you discussed].

You suggested I [their advice]. I [did it: applied on (date) / reached out to (person)], and I appreciated the steer.

If there is someone on the [team] side it would make sense for me to speak with, I would welcome the introduction.

Best regards,
[Your name]
[Program], Class of [Year] · Illinois Tech
[Phone] · [LinkedIn URL]

5 · LinkedIn connection noteSame day; two sentences

Subject  (No subject line on LinkedIn)

Hi [Name], great to meet you at [event] today. I enjoyed our conversation about [topic] and would like to stay in touch.—[Your name], Illinois Tech

6 · The update emailTwo to three months after advice

Subject  Update—I took your advice about [thing]

Dear [Name],

We spoke in [month], and you suggested I [their advice].

I did. [One or two sentences on what happened as a result.]

Thank you. It made a real difference, and I wanted you to know. No ask attached.

Best regards,
[Your name]

7 · After applying: to a recruiter7–10 business days after applying

Subject  Following up—[Role] ([Req number]), applied [Date]

Dear [Name],

I applied on [date] for the [Role] position, requisition [number], and wanted to share my interest directly.

I am a [year] in [major] at Illinois Tech. [One sentence of evidence tied to the posting, with a number if you have one.]

If it would help to see [the project or sample], I am glad to send it. Thank you for your time.

Best regards,
[Your name]
[Program], Class of [Year] · Illinois Tech
[Phone] · [LinkedIn URL]

8 · After applying: to an alum or team memberSame week you apply

Subject  Illinois Tech student—question about the [team] at [Company]

Dear [Name],

I found you through Illinois Tech’s alumni network. I am a [year] in [major], and I applied for the [Role] on your team last week.

I am not writing to ask for a referral. I would like to understand what the team values in a new [intern/analyst/engineer], so I can prepare for the real work.

Would you be open to 15 minutes in the next couple of weeks? I am happy to work around your schedule.

Thank you,
[Your name]

9 · First nudge, no replyDay 7–10, in the same thread

Subject  Re: [original subject line]

Dear [Name],

Following up on my note below. I am still very interested in [the role / the conversation].

Since I wrote, [one new thing: a project finished, a certification earned, a relevant result].

Happy to send anything that would help. Thank you.

[Your name]

10 · Final note, no replyAround day 21, then stop

Subject  Re: [original subject line]

Dear [Name],

I know things get busy, so I will leave it here after this note.

I remain interested in [the role / learning about your work], and I would welcome the chance to talk if anything changes.

Thank you, and best of luck with [the search / the project].

[Your name]

11 · Replying to a rejectionWithin a day or two

Subject  Re: Your application to [Company]

Dear [Name],

Thank you for letting me know, and for closing the loop.

I am disappointed, but I would still like to work at [Company] in the future. If you are willing, I would value a line on what would make me a stronger candidate next time.

Either way, thank you for your time and consideration.

Best regards,
[Your name]

12 · Asking for time to decideAs soon as you know you need it

Subject  [Role] offer—timing question

Dear [Name],

Thank you again for the offer for the [Role] position. I am excited about the team and the work.

I want to give this decision the attention it deserves. Would it be possible to respond by [specific date]?

I am glad to talk through any questions in the meantime.

Best regards,
[Your name]

13 · Accepting an offerIn writing, after any verbal yes

Subject  Accepting—[Role] offer

Dear [Name],

I am delighted to accept the offer for the [Role] position, starting [date], as outlined in your letter of [date].

Please let me know what you need from me and by when. I look forward to joining the team.

Best regards,
[Your name]

14 · Declining an offerPromptly, before any deadline

Subject  Thank you—[Role] offer

Dear [Name],

Thank you for the offer for the [Role] position, and for the time your team spent with me.

After careful thought, I have decided to accept another role that is a closer fit for my goals right now. This was not an easy decision.

I hope our paths cross again, and I would be glad to stay in touch.

Best regards,
[Your name]

8What gets my email ignored?
Mistakes That Cost You the Reply
▾

Try It

Check every box before you hit send:

☐A subject line that summarizes the email (not “Hi”)

☐Their name, not “Dear Sir or Madam” (“Dear Hiring Team” if you truly can’t find it)

☐Under 150 words; if it needs more, ask for a call

☐No “sorry to bother you”

☐Attachment attached (attach first, write second)

☐Sent from your Illinois Tech address

☐Signature: name, program and year, phone, LinkedIn

☐Reply, not reply-all

9Who can read my draft?
Where to Get Help
▾

Write It Now, Not Tonight

Bring the draft to a career coach. One read of a real email beats an hour of advice about emails.

Book a Career Coach →

elevate@illinoistech.edu · MTCC Suite 106 · 312.567.6800

Sources (checked October 10, 2026; links rechecked November 1, 2026): NACE Career Readiness Competencies · Illinois Tech Career Services. Templates are shapes to adapt, not scripts to send unchanged. Found a broken link? Tell us at elevate@illinoistech.edu.